The Lived Experience of Healthy Adults Following a Ketogenic diet: A Qualitative Study

Cliff J. d. C. Harvey, Grant M. Schofield, Micalla M. Williden

Journal of Holistic Performance
ISSN: 2463-7238 | DOI: 10.26712/052018
Published: 4 May 2018 

Key findings in plain English:

• Physical, and mood, energy, and cognitive effects accounted for over half of reported effects.
• 49% of effects were positive, with 8% neutral, and 43% negative.
• Negative and positive effects improved over the study course.
• The overall perception of the diet was positive.
• Most participants continued to follow a lower-carbohydrate diet after the study due to the positive experience.
• Overall, these findings suggest that the experience of a ketogenic diet is positive but highly variable between individuals.​

​

Qualitative Study | Peer-Reviewed

The Lived Experience of a Ketogenic Diet...Harvey et al. 2018
File Size:	444 kb
File Type:	pdf

Download File

---

• Abstract
• Full-Text
• Article Information

<

>

Background

Very-low-carbohydrate ketogenic diets (VLCKDs) promote benefits for a range of health conditions. However, there is little research elucidating the ‘lived experience’ of individuals undertaking these diets, and the effects of keto-induction, during adaptation to these diets.
​

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the subjective experiences of people following a very low carbohydrate, ketogenic diet.
​

Design

This paper describes the qualitative experiences of twenty-eight non-obese, non-diabetic participants, (2 males, 26 females: age ± SD: 35 ± 4 y) in a randomised controlled trial to test the effects of medium chain triglyceride (MCT) supplementation in a VLCKD on time to nutritional ketosis (NK), symptoms of keto-induction, and mood. The experience provided by the diet was rated by a free-form daily diary entry and post-study focus group. Diary entries and focus group transcription were coded inductively and grouped into common themes.
​

Results

Twenty-three participants completed the 3-week study. Physical effects accounted for over 28% of references. Other results were categorised as; mood, energy and cognition (23%), satiety and hunger (16%), cravings and temptation (11%), and sleep (8%). Overall, 49% of references were classified as ‘positive’ with 8% neutral, and 43% negative. Positive impressions were higher after participants had achieved nutritional ketosis and negative impressions higher during keto-induction. Negative impressions, both concerning physical symptoms and feelings of mood and well-being, tended towards improvement over the course of the study, and positive impressions improved. However, there was a large variation in responses, and several respondents reported adverse effects throughout the study.
​

Conclusions

Despite challenges, especially gastrointestinal effects, the overall perception of the diet was positive, and it provided benefits for wellbeing, mood, sleep, and sugar cravings which tended towards improvement over the course of the study. Negative experiences decreased as participants adapted to the VLCKD. Most participants continued post-study, using a lower-carbohydrate diet, due to these perceived benefits. Our findings suggest that the experience of a VLCKD is positive but variable. Further research on individual tolerance and response to low carbohydrate diets is warranted.

Authors

Cliff J. d. C. Harvey
ORCID | Google Scholar

Grant M. Schofield
ORCID | Google Scholar

Micalla M. Williden
​ORCID | Google Scholar

All authors: Human Potential Centre, Auckland University of Technology.

Correspondence to: Dr Cliff Harvey  cliff@hpn.ac.nz 
​

Citation

Harvey C, Schofield G, Williden M. The lived experience of healthy adults following a ketogenic diet: A qualitative study. Journal of Holistic Performance. May 2018. DOI: 10.26712/052018

Cite at Google Scholar
​